Mar 10, 2018
I have had this subscription for almost two years, and it just keeps getting better. The products are top notch--great quality and AMAZING color, and the retail value always exceeds the subscription costs. If you're in to lip products, they've recently added a lip box, too.
Dec 6, 2016
Lots of fun! The price is right (less than $15) and you get... something like 2-3 loose eyeshadows, something for the lips, plus maybe something for the cheeks (highlighter I've usually found). Usually around 4 full size items, all around geeky-gothy themes (Gremlins, Nightmare on Elm Street, Death Becomes Her, Charmed, etc). The brand is indie, which means it's run by only a few (2?) women, which means there's a huge TAT and sometimes things are not gonna be sephora perfect (for example, one of the lip colors didn't work out like they wanted so they had to put it in the next month's box. They had communicated this up front and provided recourse if you weren't gonna get the box, though). It has its followers, but personally I prefer the larger brands. Even then I've stuck around for this box. I love the themes because I too am a huge geek!
Sep 27, 2016
I wanted to like this box so much because everything I saw on the site was amazing, just my style. While the price/customer service/shipping time is all great, I was pretty disappointed in what I received. Three loose eyeshadows, two of which were super similar in color, and a color-changing lip gloss that only did a tiny bit of what it was supposed to do. I might try again at some point when the wait list opens up again, but it just seemed like even though other people really love this box, I didn't see what all the hype was about.