BoxyCharm Premium is hit or miss for me. Sometimes it is just an incredible box that the $40 spend each month is beyond worth it, and I've absolutely found some of my all-time holy grail products through this subscription. However, I've also had plenty of giveaways where the value just wasn't there. Some months the products will seem less exciting than the regular box, and other months it's better. It's genuinely made it difficult to determine if it's truly worth the extra spend to upgrade. That said, BoxyCharm still reigns supreme for me and Premium is still my last subscription standing after cancelling Ipsy, Allure, and many others. I'd say it's worth trying for at least 3-6 months, but only for someone who is a makeup / skincare junkie that is okay with a variety of products they may or may not keep / use.

I am very DISSAPPOINTED in my premium box. First off it's $39.99 not $35. Was the face sponge supposed to come with 2 sponges , cuz I only got one. Stila mascara was dried up. Face serum sticky & slimy both.... Smh

Not impressed at all😞 PRICE IS UP, QUALITY IS DOWN... SO MANY CHINTZY FILLERS -BRUSHES, MASKS, MYSTERY SERUMS, PENCILS. HOW DOES A LIP PENCIL COST $30 AND I'VE NEVER EVEN HEARD OF THE BRAND EVER BEFORE? DOES IT DO THE DISHES? IT SHOULD @ $30! ANYWAY.... BLAH